## Self-Review Report
### Design Introspection
- Clarity: well-defined — "4-pillar, 6-dimension alignment audit"
- Value: problem definition precise — "drift between intent and delivery"
- Simplicity: 6 principles = 3 theoretical + 3 engineering, no excess concepts
### Scope Lock
- Current phase: Published skill, post-refactor
- In-scope: SKILL.md, dimensions.md, README.md
- Deferred: none
### Anchors Found
- Design: README.md (design intent + principles)
- Artifact: SKILL.md, references/dimensions.md
- Skill: self-review is itself a skill (SKILL.md + references/)
- Progress: [inferred] git log on main
### Priority Dimensions
#### 1. Progress <> Design [Aligned]
- 6-dimension model consistent across all files
- Feynman + engineering principle split documented in README
#### 2. Progress <> Artifact [Aligned]
- SKILL.md frontmatter valid (name, description)
- All internal references resolve (dimensions.md exists, linked correctly)
- L2 verified: structure complete, no broken links
#### 3. Progress <> Skill [Aligned]
- No new deposit needed — stable published skill
### Cross-pillar Dimensions
#### 4. Design <> Artifact [Aligned]
- SKILL.md implements all 6 principles as embedded check questions
- dimensions.md covers all C(4,2) = 6 pillar combinations
- Report template matches process steps
#### 5. Design <> Skill [Aligned]
- Feynman principles mapped to T1/T2/T3, engineering to E1/E2/E3
- Skill deposit criteria in Dimension 3 enforces knowledge-persistence design goal
#### 6. Artifact <> Skill [Aligned]
- Frontmatter follows Agent Skills standard (name, description)
- Directory structure: SKILL.md + references/ at repo root per convention
- No junk files in skill content
### Summary
- 6/6 aligned, 0/6 drifted, 0/6 broken
## Self-Review Report
### Scope Lock
- Current phase: Episode 3 rough cut
- In-scope: filming, rough edit, audio sync
- Deferred: color grading, final mix (post-production phase)
### Priority Dimensions
#### 1. Progress <> Design [Drift]
- Script calls for 5 scenes, only 4 filmed. Scene 3 (interview) not scheduled.
#### 2. Progress <> Artifact [Aligned]
- Rough cut exists, 12:34 duration (target: 12-15 min)
- Audio synced, no dropout detected
- L2 verified: playable, continuity intact
#### 3. Progress <> Skill [Aligned]
- Editing pattern: consistent use of J-cuts per team style guide
### Summary
- 5/6 aligned, 1/6 drifted, 0/6 broken